E-Commerce

Shopify vs BigCommerce

An honest breakdown of both tools — features, pricing, and who each one is actually built for.

Shopify
Shopify
CHALLENGER

The commerce platform built for growth.

4.5 / 5 (4 ratings)
Pricing
From $39/mo
BigCommerce
BigCommerce
INCUMBENT

Enterprise e-commerce with headless power — and GMV-based pricing.

Pricing
From $39/mo (Standard); Enterprise custom
Why teams leave BigCommerce

GMV-based pricing tiers penalize growth. The platform lags behind Shopify in app ecosystem size, theme quality, and third-party integrations.

Feature Comparison

Shopify
BigCommerce
✓1.7M+ merchants worldwide
✓Multi-storefront management from one back-end
✓Built-in payment processing (Shopify Payments)
✓B2B: customer groups, quote management, price lists
✓Native subscriptions and recurring billing
✓Headless commerce with REST and GraphQL APIs
✓4,000+ app integrations via App Store
✓Native multi-currency and cross-border selling
✓Shopify Markets for international selling
✓Built-in SEO tools and AMP pages
✓POS for in-person retail
✓Open SaaS: full API access with no platform lock-in

Pros & Cons

✓ Shopify strengths

Shopify powers over 1.7 million merchants with fast storefronts, native payments, subscriptions, and an app ecosystem that handles everything from inventory to international selling.

Target user

DTC brands from early-stage to enterprise

✓ BigCommerce strengths
✓No transaction fees on any plan
✓Strong B2B and multi-storefront capabilities
✓Powerful headless commerce APIs and composable architecture
✓Good for high-volume merchants with complex catalogs
✗ BigCommerce weaknesses
✗GMV-based pricing tiers penalize revenue growth
✗Smaller app ecosystem compared to Shopify
✗Fewer high-quality themes and design flexibility
✗Less intuitive for non-technical merchants

Who Should Use Each?

Choose Shopify if…

DTC brands from early-stage to enterprise

Choose BigCommerce if…

Mid-market and enterprise retailers needing B2B, multi-storefront, or headless architecture

The Verdict

Shopify is built for dtc brands from early-stage to enterprise. BigCommerce remains the go-to for mid-market and enterprise retailers needing b2b, multi-storefront, or headless architecture. If you're evaluating both, the question is whether you need BigCommerce's depth and ecosystem — or whether you'd rather pay less, move faster, and use a tool your team will actually enjoy.

More BigCommerce alternatives